ICareGifts Reviews
ICareGifts has an overall rating of 4.9 based on 76 reviews. Customer feedback on ICareGifts is mixed: ICareGifts reviewers highlight positive aspects like unique gift selection, good customer service, fast shipping, and quality products, which strongly appeal to gift shoppers looking for special occasions. However, ICareGifts is often criticized for its higher prices, limited international shipping, occasional stock issues, and website navigation difficulties.
76 reviews
5 Stars
28
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate ICareGifts?
All ICareGifts Reviews (76)
William_urias84
May 20, 2026
"Fresh and Better Than Expected"
Everything tasted really fresh. I wasn’t expecting anything too special, but it ended up being better than I thought. No complaints from me.
0
Reply
HERMAN
May 18, 2026
"Showed up on time, but I’m still a little torn"
My order went through without any problems and it arrived right when they said it would, so I really can’t complain. At the same time, I wasn’t exactly blown away or anything. It was smooth and reliable, which I appreciate, but also kind of just average. Overall, it did what it was supposed to do.
0
Reply
stanley1989
May 10, 2026
"I had been meaning to send…"
I had been meaning to send something to a family member for a while and finally sat down to do it through icaregifts.com. I wasn’t really in the mood to deal with a confusing website or a bunch of random checkout pages, so I was glad it ended up being straightforward. I found what I needed quickly, put it in the cart, and paid without any weird extra steps getting in the way. The whole thing was clear and didn’t take much time, which I appreciated. it was just nice using a site that worked the way you’d expect it to.
0
Reply
PeggyCommings
May 09, 2026
"Clear and easy to use"
I really appreciated that ICareGifts had their return policy laid out clearly instead of burying it in some ridiculous wall of confusing fine print. I knew exactly what to do if there was an issue with my order, which made me feel a lot more comfortable buying. The site was simple to use, and I found the info I needed without any hassle. 5 stars from me.
0
Reply
dmaalika13
May 06, 2026
"Feeding your family"
I think it’s great that you guys offer coupons.
0
Reply
AmandaRoiger_22
April 24, 2026
"I found everything I needed pretty…"
I found everything I needed fast, which surprised me a little because I thought I’d be wandering around longer. Checkout was easy too, though I was kind of confused for a second about where to go. Overall, it worked out fine.
0
Reply
james2001
April 14, 2026
"Easy to order on my break"
I ordered from my phone while I was on break, and it was painless. The pages loaded fine, checkout didn’t act up, and I got the confirmation right away. I remember there was a tiny coffee stain on the corner of my napkin the whole time, for some reason. Anyway, it was nice being able to send something without having to call around.
0
Reply
AmberGrullon_56
April 12, 2026
"Better than I expected"
I ordered a gift pack and was pleasantly surprised by the quality. Everything looked fresh, nicely packed, and just felt better than I thought it would. No complaints from me at all.
0
Reply
Eunice.cunningham
April 11, 2026
"Quick and easy setup"
I made my account in just a few minutes, and it wasn’t no hassle at all. Everything was clear, and it worked fine on the first try
0
Reply
charlie-Persons
April 10, 2026
"My Brother got it just fine"
My brother got it with no issues, so Thanks a lot!
0
Reply
KatherineHarrison
March 28, 2026
"Made Sending a Gift So Much Easier"
I was relieved to see my loved one’s facility listed on iCareGifts. I had checked a few other sites and couldn’t find it anywhere, so using this felt like the sensible choice instead of spending more time calling around. The ordering process was quick, and it saved me a lot of hassle. Really helpful service.
0
Reply
AmandaBrixey_77
March 19, 2026
"Finally, No Surprise Fees!"
I used icaregifts to send my cousin a snack pack, i was bracing myself for some dramatic last-second fee jump because that always seems to happen everywhere. But nope! The fees were actually clear before I paid, and nothing weird suddenly appeared at checkout like some kind of financial jump scare. Shipping and the service fee were listed separately too, which made it way easier to see what I was paying for. I did spend a minute comparing prices, and some items still felt a little pricey, but overall it seemed honest. Giving it 4 stars for that.
0
Reply
joseph1980
March 08, 2026
"Way better communication than others I’ve tried"
They kept me updated the whole time, which I really appreciated. I’ve used similar companies before where I had to keep chasing for info, but this was smooth from start to finish. No issues at all
0
Reply
bill1977
March 08, 2026
"Worked out just like I hoped"
I was overthinking it and wondering if I’d somehow messed up the order, but everything showed up exactly as I picked it. Nothing was missing, and even the note was right. It got to my cousin without any mixup, which was the main thing I was worried about
0
Reply
Sang-conti
March 06, 2026
"Pretty Good Overall"
Most of the things I needed were available, which is really what matters at the end of the day. One snack I wanted was out of stock, but that happens sometimes and wasn’t a big deal.
0
Reply
zacharylopez2046
March 06, 2026
"Fast replies made it easy"
I had a question about my order, and customer service got back to me quicker than I expected. They explained what was happening clearly, and everything was sorted out without a lot of back and forth.
0
Reply
Joseph_wright84
February 27, 2026
"I used icaregifts.com the payment process was…"
I used icaregifts.com the payment process was painless. My card went through on the first try, and I got the confirmation right away. No confusing errors, no random extra steps, nothing that made me second-guess it. It felt straightforward and reliable, which I definitely appreciated
0
Reply
CindyLake
February 13, 2026
"Fair prices and no weird surprises"
I’ve used icaregifts.com a couple of times now, and the prices have seemed fair to me. I didn’t notice anything that felt seriously marked up, and checkout was easy enough. I did have a quick question once, and support basically said, “Yep, that’s the total you’ll see at checkout,” which was nice because there weren’t any random surprises later. It’s a solid option if you want to send something without spending a ton
0
Reply
andre_Mulford92
February 13, 2026
"Recent order was surprisingly easy"
I just used ICareGifts recently to send something to a family member, and my impression is positive right now because the whole process was clearer than I expected. What I liked most was that the rules were laid out in a way that actually made sense. The site showed what items were allowed and what couldn’t be sent, so I wasn’t sitting there guessing or worrying it might get rejected later. Checkout was simple too. Nothing fancy, but it worked fine, and the policies were explained in plain enough language that I felt comfortable placing the order
0
Reply
michaelwarren3184
February 11, 2026
"Quick and Easy Fix"
I reached out with an issue and they got it fixed way faster than I expected. Super smooth experience overall, what more could I ask for??
0
Reply
Have a question about ICareGifts?
Log in to ask your ICareGifts question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
